On the first evening we began with looking at exactly what a crime is. Sadly, there is no satisfactory definition, we just know it when we see it. People’s ideas about what kind of behaviour should be prohibited by the criminal law change over the course of the years, to the point where what is regarded as a crime at one time ceases to be so regarded at a later stage, e.g. suicide, homosexuality, abortion and so on. The law has developed piecemeal, with no coherent plan.
Does immoral behaviour make things a crime? That rather depends. Consider murder. Immoral certainly, but arguments for euthanasia temper that view. Similarly, stealing to feed a child may be considered in a different light to those who steal as a way of life. If immorality has something to do with it, why isn’t adultery a crime? Why not prostitution per se?
In the past the House of Lords have tried to impose moralistic values on us, e.g. in the case of Shaw v DPP [1962] – the ‘Ladies Directory’ case. There the courts convicted a man of an offence previously unheard of – conspiracy to corrupt public morals.
If the criminal law is to punish people, and civil law to compensate them, why is it possible to obtain compensation in a criminal court? Why can a civil court impose exemplary damages to punish people?
Some lawyers suggest that a crime is an offence which contravenes the criminal law. Doesn’t seem helpful to me.
We then discussed codification, an attempt to place all of the law on a subject under one umbrella statute. Desirable, certainly. Achievable? No. Consider the offences of dishonesty, all originally found in the Theft Act 1968. Two further statutes gave diluted the attempt at codification.
Criminal law didn’t grow, because no-one seemed to care. The Court of Appeal (criminal Division) was born in 1907, but heard only 21 appeals in the following 53 years. Yes, 53 years. There were no senior judges in this court and the influence of the House of Lords was minimal, as the Attorney General had first to certify that a point of exceptional public importance was involved.
In 1979 Lord Devlin stated they (judges) felt that the verdict of a jury properly directed in law should be unassailable and that to allow an appeal from it cast an unnecessary doubt on its reliability.
Given the above it is not surprising that no-one cared. In 1953 Glanville Williams published: Criminal Law: The General Part. Smith & Hogan were next, with the standard Criminal Law text book, but this began only in 1965. Nowadays, of course, things are very different. There are specialist sets of reports and periodicals such as the Criminal Appeal Reports and The Criminal Law Review as well as a very large number of texts at all levels. Very importantly, the Criminal Law Revision Committee (est. 1959, and no longer existing) and the Law Commission (est. 1965) have been created to look at the law, including criminal matters. In addition, the 1966 Practice Statement allowed for the House of Lords to change their mind if necessary. Consider DPPNI v Lynch with Howe, and Anderton v Ryan with Shivpuri.
These decisions demonstrate a state of uncertainty in the criminal law, and it is often difficult (if not impossible) to accurately state the ratio of a case. In Pagett the leading judge actually stated that he was not trying to set a precedent for further cases of a similar nature. In Morgan it was thought for many years that the defence of mistake applied only to rape, but this has turned out not to be the case.
Finally, we looked at the classification of crimes, achieved by:
SOURCE: i.e. crimes may be treated as common law (e.g. murder) or as statutory offences (e.g. theft). More and more crimes are regulated by statute.
BY METHOD OF TRIAL: we now distinguish between summary offences, triable only in a summary court; indictable offences (those triable only on indictment, in the Crown Court; and offences that are triable either way. Summary crimes are generally treated as the lesser crimes, in contrast to indictable offences which are or ought to be much more serious. Either way offences are thus an intermediate group.
BY REFERENCE TO POWERS OF ARREST: since January 2006 this has fell into disuse, as the police now enjoy a power of arrest for all offences, no matter how minor. Before the arrest can take place, however, it has to pass a ‘necessity test’.
Does immoral behaviour make things a crime? That rather depends. Consider murder. Immoral certainly, but arguments for euthanasia temper that view. Similarly, stealing to feed a child may be considered in a different light to those who steal as a way of life. If immorality has something to do with it, why isn’t adultery a crime? Why not prostitution per se?
In the past the House of Lords have tried to impose moralistic values on us, e.g. in the case of Shaw v DPP [1962] – the ‘Ladies Directory’ case. There the courts convicted a man of an offence previously unheard of – conspiracy to corrupt public morals.
If the criminal law is to punish people, and civil law to compensate them, why is it possible to obtain compensation in a criminal court? Why can a civil court impose exemplary damages to punish people?
Some lawyers suggest that a crime is an offence which contravenes the criminal law. Doesn’t seem helpful to me.
We then discussed codification, an attempt to place all of the law on a subject under one umbrella statute. Desirable, certainly. Achievable? No. Consider the offences of dishonesty, all originally found in the Theft Act 1968. Two further statutes gave diluted the attempt at codification.
Criminal law didn’t grow, because no-one seemed to care. The Court of Appeal (criminal Division) was born in 1907, but heard only 21 appeals in the following 53 years. Yes, 53 years. There were no senior judges in this court and the influence of the House of Lords was minimal, as the Attorney General had first to certify that a point of exceptional public importance was involved.
In 1979 Lord Devlin stated they (judges) felt that the verdict of a jury properly directed in law should be unassailable and that to allow an appeal from it cast an unnecessary doubt on its reliability.
Given the above it is not surprising that no-one cared. In 1953 Glanville Williams published: Criminal Law: The General Part. Smith & Hogan were next, with the standard Criminal Law text book, but this began only in 1965. Nowadays, of course, things are very different. There are specialist sets of reports and periodicals such as the Criminal Appeal Reports and The Criminal Law Review as well as a very large number of texts at all levels. Very importantly, the Criminal Law Revision Committee (est. 1959, and no longer existing) and the Law Commission (est. 1965) have been created to look at the law, including criminal matters. In addition, the 1966 Practice Statement allowed for the House of Lords to change their mind if necessary. Consider DPPNI v Lynch with Howe, and Anderton v Ryan with Shivpuri.
These decisions demonstrate a state of uncertainty in the criminal law, and it is often difficult (if not impossible) to accurately state the ratio of a case. In Pagett the leading judge actually stated that he was not trying to set a precedent for further cases of a similar nature. In Morgan it was thought for many years that the defence of mistake applied only to rape, but this has turned out not to be the case.
Finally, we looked at the classification of crimes, achieved by:
SOURCE: i.e. crimes may be treated as common law (e.g. murder) or as statutory offences (e.g. theft). More and more crimes are regulated by statute.
BY METHOD OF TRIAL: we now distinguish between summary offences, triable only in a summary court; indictable offences (those triable only on indictment, in the Crown Court; and offences that are triable either way. Summary crimes are generally treated as the lesser crimes, in contrast to indictable offences which are or ought to be much more serious. Either way offences are thus an intermediate group.
BY REFERENCE TO POWERS OF ARREST: since January 2006 this has fell into disuse, as the police now enjoy a power of arrest for all offences, no matter how minor. Before the arrest can take place, however, it has to pass a ‘necessity test’.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home