Friday, September 29, 2006

Thursday 29 September 2006

We began with an explanation of the burden and standard of proof in criminal proceedings.

The general rule in criminal cases is that the prosecution have the LEGAL burden of proving the defendant’s guilt. The rule derives from the leading case of Woolmington v DPP [1935]. The accused was charged with the murder of his wife. He admitted that he had shot her but claimed that the gun had gone off by accident. The trial judge, in directing the jury, stated that if the jury were satisfied that the accused had killed his wife then it was for him to satisfy the jury that it was an accident. The accused was convicted and appealed. The case went to the Court of Appeal where the direction and conviction were upheld, and to the House of Lords where the direction was overruled and the conviction quashed. The House of Lords reaffirmed the principle that it was for the prosecution to prove every element of the offence charged, including disproving any proper defence such as self-defence.

As an illustration of the Woolmington principle, in a case of theft the prosecution have the legal burden of proving that the defendant dishonestly appropriated property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving the other of it.

There are a number of exceptions to the Woolmington principle where the defence have the legal burden of proving one or more facts in issue. It is not necessary for you to be aware of them, but briefly, they are:

INSANITY: McNaghten Rules [1843].

EXPRESS STATUTORY EXCEPTIONS: in some statutes, Parliament has expressly placed the legal burden of proof on the defence on or more of the facts in issue. For example, s139 CRIMINAL JUSTICE ACT 1988 creates an offence of possession of a knife in a public place. s139(4) provides that the possession in a public place is not an offence where the defendant can show he has good reason or lawful authority for possessing the knife. The defence have the legal burden of proving that the accused has such good reason or lawful authority.

The same principle applies to ss 2 and 4 HOMICIDE ACT 1957 where Parliament has expressly provided that the defence has the legal burden of proving the defences of diminished responsibility under s2 or acting in pursuance of a suicide pact under s4.

IMPLIED STATUTORY EXCEPTIONS: s101 Magistrates' Courts Act.

The general rule is that the party which has the legal burden of proving a fact in issue also has an EVIDENTIAL burden. It is only by tendering evidence in relation to each fact in issue, that a party will discharge its legal burden. The evidential burden is therefore satisfied by producing evidence in a number of forms including most commonly the oral testimony of a witness in court; documentary evidence; photographic and video evidence or real evidence. The evidential burden is the practical way a party discharges its legal burden by putting evidence before the court.

I used an analogy with a game of tennis to explain this concept.

The STANDARD of proof required of the prosecution: beyond all reasonable doubt.

Where this burden falls on the defence they are required to prove the assertion only on the balance of probabilities (as used in civil cases).

THE PURPOSE OF CRIMINAL LAW

Traditionally, the criminal justice system has emphasised the need to punish the offender, but the aims are said to try to satisfy four criteria:

Retribution
Deterrence
Reformation
Reparation

A discussion followed on the effectiveness of the criminal justice system to meet such aims.

There are, generally, four sentencing options available to a court, namely:

Imprisonment
Community penalties
Fines
Discharges

We now turn to far more interesting material, beginning with

FUNDAMENTAL PRINCIPLES OF CRIMINAL LIABILITY

It is usually argued that three basic elements must be proved to establish criminal The basic elements liability:

(1) a guilty act (actus reus);

(2) a guilty mind (mens rea);

(3) the absence of any defence.

However, the precise form of these requirements may vary from offence to offence. Thus, in some offences, the mens rea element may be so limited that they are known as “strict liability”‘ offences.

ACTUS REUS

This refers to the external elements of a crime and includes all those parts of an actus reus offence except those which relate to the accused’s state of mind. In other words, the actus reus of a crime includes all the elements of the crime, minus the mens rea, and may include an omission to act.

Exceptionally, there are some crimes which do not even seem to require proof of any conduct by D, but merely that a STATE OF AFFAIRS existed. The danger in such offences is that the courts will hold that, if no conduct need be proved, then no voluntariness need be proved. In other words, D might be liable even if the state of affairs did not conic about through his fault. See:

Larsonneur [1933] and Winzar v Chief Constable of Kent [1983].

There are occasions where an omission may suffice, and we began to consider these:

A CONTRACT between D and V or between D and a third party, X.

Pittwood [1902]: negligently failing to close level crossing gates so that a person crossing the railway line was struck & killed by a train. D’s duty arose out of his employment by X as a level crossing keeper;

A PARENTAL, FAMILY, OR EQUIVALENT RELATIONSHIP. Thus, a father and the woman with whom he was living were guilty of murder in Gibbons and Proctor [1918] for deliberately withholding food from his child.

There are, of course, specific obligations placed on parents by statutes such as the CHILDREN AND YOUNG PERSONS ACT 1933. It is unclear how far the court might go in developing obligations in other relationships (for instance, between friends or those who share accommodation and so on);

A STATUTE. Many statutes make it an offence to fail to do something. Inevitably, this creates a duty to act (for instance, the ROAD TRAFFIC ACT 1988 s170 makes it an offence to fail to stop and give various details in connection with a road traffic accident involving personal injury or damage to property.

A PUBLIC OFFICE.

Dytham [1979]: a police constable on duty was held to have committed an offence when he knowingly failed to intervene when V was ejected from a night-club and beaten to death by a ‘bouncer’.

A VOLUNTARY ASSUMPTION OF RESPONSIBILITY BY D. This is where we continue next time.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home