Thursday 15 March 2007
Tonight we continued with our look at CRIMINAL DAMAGE.
DESTROY OR DAMAGE.
The question is one of fact and degree. The destruction/damage need not be permanent, so that graffiti on a wall is capable of amounting to damage - ROE v KINGERLEE [1986]. Similarly, in HARDMAN AND ANOTHER v CHIEF CONSTABLE OF AVON & SOMERSET CONSTABULARY [1986], the Crown Court held that painting silhouettes on the pavement using water-soluble paint amounted to damage, for the local authority would have to pay to have them removed.
The successful cases all involve an expense in putting the damage right.
PROPERTY is defined in s10(1) and it refers only to tangible property. But the property may be real or personal and it includes money.
Also included are wild creatures that have been tamed or are ordinarily kept in captivity, and any other wild creatures or their carcasses provided they have been reduced into possession which have not been lost or abandoned, or they are in the course of being reduced into possession. This is the same as for theft.
Excluded are wild mushrooms and wild flowers and foliage.
BELONGING TO ANOTHER. According to s10(2), this means that the property belongs to the person who has custody or control of it, or who has a proprietary right or interest in it.
“Custody” means physical custody; ‘control’ means the right to determine what will be done with the property.
THE AGGRAVATED OFFENCE. Some strange decisions here.
STEER [1987]. The House of Lords held that, in relation to s1(2)(b), it must be shown that the danger to life resulted from the destruction to the property, so that D must have intended to endanger life, or been reckless as to whether life would be endangered by the destruction/damage which he caused. S fired an automatic rifle at the door and bedroom window of the bungalow of his former business partner who was in the bedroom at the time. There could be no conviction under s1(2)(b) because the danger to life was caused by the shot from the rifle and not by the damage to the window.
Two later cases from the Court of Appeal both distinguished STEER.
In WARWICK [1995] D pushed a heavy coping-stone onto a train passing beneath a bridge. The stone partly broke through the roof showering passengers with material. D was guilty because he was reckless as to the danger to life from the roof material (not from the stone itself).
In WEBSTER [1995] D was guilty because he was reckless as to the danger to life where he threw a brick from a car at the windscreen of a pursuing police car. Though the damage to the windscreen did not directly threaten the life of the driver, the driver might lose control of the police car on account of the damage to the windscreen and thus life would have been endangered.
This is satisfactory where the envisaged destruction coincides with that which was actually caused. But where what is envisaged was much greater than what was actually caused, we must consider the envisaged destruction and not that which was brought about - DUDLEY [1989] D threw a fire-bomb at a house which resulted in a high sheet of flame. But the occupants of the house quickly put out the fire and only a small amount of damage was done. D could not avoid conviction under s1 (2) by arguing that the damage that actually resulted was insufficient to endanger life.
THREATENING TO DESTROY OR DAMAGE PROPERTY. By s2, a person who without lawful excuse makes to another a threat, intending that the other would fear it would be carried out;
(a) to destroy or damage property belonging to that other or a third person; or
(b) to destroy or damage his own property in a way which he knows is likely to endanger the life of that other or a third person;
shall be guilty of an offence.
POSSESSION OFFENCES. By s3 CDA 1971 it is an offence where a person who has anything in his custody or under his control intending without lawful excuse to use it or cause or permit another to use it:
(a) to destroy or damage any property belonging some other person; or
(b) to destroy or damage his own or the user’s property in a way which he knows is likely to endanger the life of some other person.
And with that note the teaching is over. We have arrived at the end of the course, and from now on we shall be concerning ourselves with examination techniques and revision. I handed out a previous examination paper for use next week, and will then be using paper handouts each week for our revision. Consequently this will be the last post on this blog.
DESTROY OR DAMAGE.
The question is one of fact and degree. The destruction/damage need not be permanent, so that graffiti on a wall is capable of amounting to damage - ROE v KINGERLEE [1986]. Similarly, in HARDMAN AND ANOTHER v CHIEF CONSTABLE OF AVON & SOMERSET CONSTABULARY [1986], the Crown Court held that painting silhouettes on the pavement using water-soluble paint amounted to damage, for the local authority would have to pay to have them removed.
The successful cases all involve an expense in putting the damage right.
PROPERTY is defined in s10(1) and it refers only to tangible property. But the property may be real or personal and it includes money.
Also included are wild creatures that have been tamed or are ordinarily kept in captivity, and any other wild creatures or their carcasses provided they have been reduced into possession which have not been lost or abandoned, or they are in the course of being reduced into possession. This is the same as for theft.
Excluded are wild mushrooms and wild flowers and foliage.
BELONGING TO ANOTHER. According to s10(2), this means that the property belongs to the person who has custody or control of it, or who has a proprietary right or interest in it.
“Custody” means physical custody; ‘control’ means the right to determine what will be done with the property.
THE AGGRAVATED OFFENCE. Some strange decisions here.
STEER [1987]. The House of Lords held that, in relation to s1(2)(b), it must be shown that the danger to life resulted from the destruction to the property, so that D must have intended to endanger life, or been reckless as to whether life would be endangered by the destruction/damage which he caused. S fired an automatic rifle at the door and bedroom window of the bungalow of his former business partner who was in the bedroom at the time. There could be no conviction under s1(2)(b) because the danger to life was caused by the shot from the rifle and not by the damage to the window.
Two later cases from the Court of Appeal both distinguished STEER.
In WARWICK [1995] D pushed a heavy coping-stone onto a train passing beneath a bridge. The stone partly broke through the roof showering passengers with material. D was guilty because he was reckless as to the danger to life from the roof material (not from the stone itself).
In WEBSTER [1995] D was guilty because he was reckless as to the danger to life where he threw a brick from a car at the windscreen of a pursuing police car. Though the damage to the windscreen did not directly threaten the life of the driver, the driver might lose control of the police car on account of the damage to the windscreen and thus life would have been endangered.
This is satisfactory where the envisaged destruction coincides with that which was actually caused. But where what is envisaged was much greater than what was actually caused, we must consider the envisaged destruction and not that which was brought about - DUDLEY [1989] D threw a fire-bomb at a house which resulted in a high sheet of flame. But the occupants of the house quickly put out the fire and only a small amount of damage was done. D could not avoid conviction under s1 (2) by arguing that the damage that actually resulted was insufficient to endanger life.
THREATENING TO DESTROY OR DAMAGE PROPERTY. By s2, a person who without lawful excuse makes to another a threat, intending that the other would fear it would be carried out;
(a) to destroy or damage property belonging to that other or a third person; or
(b) to destroy or damage his own property in a way which he knows is likely to endanger the life of that other or a third person;
shall be guilty of an offence.
POSSESSION OFFENCES. By s3 CDA 1971 it is an offence where a person who has anything in his custody or under his control intending without lawful excuse to use it or cause or permit another to use it:
(a) to destroy or damage any property belonging some other person; or
(b) to destroy or damage his own or the user’s property in a way which he knows is likely to endanger the life of some other person.
And with that note the teaching is over. We have arrived at the end of the course, and from now on we shall be concerning ourselves with examination techniques and revision. I handed out a previous examination paper for use next week, and will then be using paper handouts each week for our revision. Consequently this will be the last post on this blog.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home